Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's the standard dating scheme used in archaeology and some areas of geology for material that is carbon dated. As mentioned on the wikipedia page that OP linked to, "present" is actually a standard date: January 1, 1950; chosen because material from later dates can not be reliably measured [using carbon dating] due to nuclear testing.


So the present is January 1, 1950, and we're living in the future?


You're always living in the future if you wait a second.


No that is when radioactive forms of carbon start to push us into a different situation with regards to radiocarbon dating. It is basically pre nuclear weapons and post now.


what about BCE (as in "Before Common Era"), i thought this was the pc way of expressing this in our post-religious world of tomorrow!? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_era


I'm aware of that.

> "present" is actually a standard date: January 1, 1950

which is an abuse of the English langauge, since "present" actually means "now." Scientists should not overload pre-existing English words to mean other things.


I would state the argument as follows: We should use the term "before nuclear testing", abbreviated as BNT. It is more precise than "before present", which will become more inaccurate over time, whereas "before nuclear testing" will always have the same meaning.


There is no need for a new time reference at all. That's the point.

If someone actually needs to say "before nuclear testing," which is very rare, they should say "before nuclear testing."


> Scientists should not overload pre-existing English words to mean other things

Why not? Because it confuses the overly-pedantic?


Bah! I say that the plebs outside the ivory towers should stop using overloading __scientific__ terminology!

Have you ever used "dynamic" while not talking about physical forces? BOOM: you are an abuser! Repent! Repent!


Computer scientists should stop overloading phrases like "over load" to mean other things.

Dark ages Europeans should stop overloading Latin words like "lingua" to mean other things.

Modern humans should stop overloading words like "existing" to mean exactly the same thing...


You are attacking a straw man.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: