Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yeah, everyone remembers the famous 8 lane interstates built by the Romans, cutting through Europe, with gas stations every 16 miles. The only thing we needed to adapt were the road signs!

So you see no qualitative difference between a couple of horse carriage crossing the North American plains, and an Interstate system (that requires no stopping) with gas stations, motels, parking lots, malls, suburbs?

Have you looked at maps of cities with roads and parking lots? Cities in north America are literally built / rebuilt around cars, cities in Europe heavily modified.

Or, conversely, that means you find any advance towards autonomy in cars, in their current form, such as lane assistants, or working well in good weather on interstates, etc. is completely worthless?



There is a huge difference between a technology that is useful in the current world, as cars were at their inception, but can be significantly be improved by infrastructure; and a technology that requires a huge change in the world's infrastructure before it becomes useful.

That is, if autonomous cars can improve safety or convenience on current infrastructure, they will prevail, and new infrastructure will develop with them in mind. But if they are only useful after such changes, they will likely linger for decades before any adoption.


You did not answer: Do you find any advance towards autonomy in cars, in their current form, such as lane assistants, or working well in good weather on interstates, etc. is completely worthless?

Autonomy today is in the same situation that cars once were; even the current state of 'autonomy' has obvious advantages already and will only become more in the future.

Edit: How do you think cars were useful at their inception? Slow, with a range of a few miles, needed to be rebuilt every few miles, gas to be bought in pharmacies. Quite a bit had to change before cars became something practically useful beyond showing 'I am rich'.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: