Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Which is why you screen tanks with infantry.


Not sure what you think a screen is... but it doesn't hide anything. A screen is about finding, not hiding.


Yes, exactly. The infantry screen the tanks from enemy infantry ATGM groups. Everything that makes enemy infantry with ATGMs more effective tank hunters makes infantry screening the tanks more effective at countering them.


> The infantry screen the tanks from enemy infantry

Then you mean the infantry screen the enemy infantry from the tanks. You screen the threat, not what you're protecting.


There is nothing wrong with "The infantry screen the tanks from enemy infantry". Screening is just the act of keeping two things separated. It does not matter which side of the from they appear. Either way is correct. If you want to go the protection route, "The infantry protect the tanks from enemy infantry" is obviously intended over "The infantry protect the enemy infantry from the tanks".


> There is nothing wrong with "The infantry screen the tanks from enemy infantry". Screening is just the act of keeping two things separated. It does not matter which side of the from they appear. Either way is correct.

It isn’t! I’m a professional in this field.

You're confusing a screen with a guard or cover force. Different tactical actions.


> It isn’t!

It is to the average person!

> I’m a professional in this field.

Good for you! Most of us are not professionals in this field and are using average people language. Adjusting to your audience is a thing. If it is wrong in professional speak, just realize you are not likely talking to other professionals and mention that something has a specific meaning in your field. People will just take that tidbit of information.


There's no point in screening the threat where there is nothing to be threatened, so in practice screening moves with the formation.

But in any case, it seems you just want to double down on that fine hnews tradition of utterly valueless semantic quibbling, which I will not participate in further.


> utterly valueless semantic quibbling

They're technical terms - entirely different tactical actions. You're confusing a screen with a guard or covering force.

If you asked someone to screen and really you mean cover or guard, you've fucked up.


> They're technical terms - entirely different tactical actions.

Right here! This is so close to what I was talking about. You might refer to the specific field the are technical terms in.

> You're confusing a screen with a guard or covering force.

Nah, likely a non-professional.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: