Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm by no mean an expert in passwords/cyrpto and the like but it sounds to me that his idea of generating passwords from the service name and a master password is a good bad idea.

Basically, his passwords are made of two variable strings: one is the service (easy to guess if you're target a specific account, which in his case you must anyway) and a master password that likely doesn't vary much from one identity to another.

Doing this is basically opening the door to anybody who could gain access to his generation algorithm. I have no maths to back me up but I made a quick proof of concept that I ran against /usr/share/dict/words and managed to find one collision in ~100000 tests (I was generating passphrases though).

I'm going to keep on investigating and try to generate passwords instead of passphrases.



You've still got to do it right. If I phish your twitter account and discover your password is "twitter-iloveyoujane", you can bet I'm going to see if "facebook-iloveyoujane" will get me into your facebook account...

And I'd be astounded if there weren't already automated tools that do this for every website in the alexa top 1000...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: