Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

His trans critiques are very reasonable though, particularly when he talks about males in women's sports, males in women's prisons, and the social contagion aspect of this type of identity.

These are the questions that cut across the entire political spectrum, as there are plenty on the left questioning the excesses of this activist movement too.



Depends.

I agree they are reasonable, but it’s kind of like a cock tease dog whistle (maybe a less crude way to put it is a feint dog whistle).

If you take a Kanye, and he says ‘I love Hitler’, that’s a blow horn. But if you say, ‘There are a lot of Jews in Hollywood, and look at all that stuff that’s going on in Palestine’, now we’re angling. Everything you are saying is reasonable, but you are reconnoitering around the rim of a specific demographic.

I guess the question is, is this subtle play going past you, or are you letting it get a pass?

He’s keeping one foot in the ring because it’s a pragmatic way of acknowledging the existence of those viewpoints.

I’m not saying black people commit a lot of crime, but look at this shoplifting video. Proceeds to show black people looting. We need to do something about crime.

There are ways to hold that audience without being an outright demagogue.

I like Rogan, but this manipulation in the interest of holding that broader audience smells a little. Integrity is the word I guess.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: